SC Collegium defers decision on Justice Joseph's elevation again

SC Collegium defers decision on Justice Joseph's elevation again

At its last meeting on May 11, the Collegium had agreed in principle to reiterate its recommendation for elevating Justice Joseph as a judge of the apex court, nearly three weeks after it was returned by the Centre.

Sources said it was considering sending Justice Joseph's name, along with other names being considered for Supreme Court judgeships.

At the May 11 meeting, the five-member Collegium agreed "in principle" to reiterate its January 10 recommendation to the government to elevate Justice Joseph.

Which means that even the recommendation of Justice Joseph's name gets delayed in the process. The collegium had earlier made a decision to consider other names from various high courts for appointment as SC judges and had deferred the deliberations to May 16.

According to the sources, since Justice K.M. Joseph's name had already been "in principle" reiterated at the last meeting, not much of Wednesday's discussion revolved around him. The Centre had sent back Justice Joseph's name for reconsideration.

High court opens door to sports betting
The pro-gambling side cited the Tenth Amendment as its main argument, while the anti-gambling side cited the supremacy clause. America has seen a cultural shift on the question of sports gambling in recent times. "My inclination is to say they won't".

The resolution had, in fact, specifically mentioned that the decision was being taken after considering the combined seniority of chief justices and senior puisne judges of high courts, apart from their merit and integrity.

It had also said that the Kerala High Court being comparatively a smaller court, with a sanctioned strength of 42 judges, was a parent high court for Supreme Court judge Justice Kurian Joseph, and the Chief Justices of three high courts - Justice KM Joseph himself (Uttarakhand), Justice TB Radhakrishnan (Chhattisgarh) and Justice Antony Dominic (Kerala). Law Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad denies that the centre's decision had anything to do with the Uttarakhand High Court Chief Justice's 2016 verdict cancelling President's rule in the state.

It is not first time that the government has sought to block a collegium decision on Justice Joseph.

The NJAC judgment marked the beginning of Justice Chelameswars journey of dissent which took several shapes later in the form of letter wars with CJIs on the issue of lack of transparency in collegium proceedings and public utterances to the effect.

Related Articles

  • With friends like Trump, who needs enemies: EU chief

    With friends like Trump, who needs enemies: EU chief

    The EU has discussed instituting a so-called blocking statute, which would shield European companies doing business with Iran.
    Kristen Stewart flouts footwear ban at Cannes Film Festival

    Kristen Stewart flouts footwear ban at Cannes Film Festival

    Kristen Stewart ditched her heels on the way to " BlacKkKlansman " premiere at the Cannes Film Festival. This peaceful protest was seen on the red carpet before the premiere of " Solo: A Star Wars story ".
    SpecialEffect collaborate in development of new Xbox Adaptive Controller

    SpecialEffect collaborate in development of new Xbox Adaptive Controller

    Third-party manufacturers have been brought on board to provide external input devices to use alongside the Adaptive Controller. Microsoft is calling it the Xbox Adaptive Controller and it will help people with disabilities play games on Xbox.
  • Antoine Griezmann refuses to discuss Atletico Madrid future

    Antoine Griezmann refuses to discuss Atletico Madrid future

    The French club's hopes faded after Payet went off injured in the 31st with what appeared to be a thigh injury. The irrepressible Griezmann started and finished the move for his second, four minutes into the second half.
    EA Games announces Battlefield V, to be revealed on May 23rd

    EA Games announces Battlefield V, to be revealed on May 23rd

    We've been hearing rumors for a while now that the next Battlefield game will be revealed at E3 or EA Play next month. However, the upcoming live stream will be the determining factor if Operations will be in this year's Battlefield .
    Woman detained after feces flinging incident at Langley Tim Hortons

    Woman detained after feces flinging incident at Langley Tim Hortons

    It was deleted from the self-broadcasting platform a little too late as it was already widely circulated on Twitter . Tim Hortons says it will be working with the owner of the restaurant to help look into the whole situation.
  • American Bishop Will Give Sermon At Royal Wedding

    American Bishop Will Give Sermon At Royal Wedding

    The move is a break from royal custom, as wedding addresses are traditionally given by senior members of the Church of England. As bishop in North Carolina, he was one of the first to allow same-sex marriages to be performed in churches there.
    Senate OK's bill in bid to retain net neutrality

    Senate OK's bill in bid to retain net neutrality

    Yesterday, the US Senate passed the Congressional Review Act , a resolution to restore Net Neutrality provisions. The three Senate Republicans included Susan Collins, Maine; John Kennedy, La.; and Lisa Murkowski, Alaska.
    DRC: 3rd Ebola case confirmed, in urban area

    DRC: 3rd Ebola case confirmed, in urban area

    The World Health Organization sent 5,400 doses of the experimental Ebola vaccine to Congo on Wednesday, according to the health minister.
  • Shining Sonam Kapoor At Cannes

    Shining Sonam Kapoor At Cannes

    She has never backed away from voicing her opinions on the matter, despite having to be under constant scrutiny as a celebrity. Meanwhile, Sonam attended the red carpet at the Cannes International Film Festival as a brand ambassador for L'Oreal Paris.
    'Flower' keeps Vegas fresh despite late Game 3 flurry from Jets

    'Flower' keeps Vegas fresh despite late Game 3 flurry from Jets

    Defensively, the Winnipeg Jets are allowing 2.6 goals per game and are killing 81.8 percent of their opponents power plays. Marc Andre-Fleury was as sharp as ever in net with 33 saves, but he didn't have to do much for the first half of the game.
    WWE superstar Ronda Rousey will be pregnant Soon

    WWE superstar Ronda Rousey will be pregnant Soon

    She also said that she thinks she will come out the victor, but regardless, the WWE universe should be entertained with the event. Rousey made a point in her response to Nia Jax when she said, "There are other women who deserve the opportunity".